GST on Personal Guarantee by Director to Bank: When is 18% GST Applicable?
Introduction
When a company approaches a bank or financial institution for a business loan, cash credit facility, overdraft facility, or other credit arrangement, the lender may ask its directors or promoters to provide a personal guarantee.
A personal guarantee is a commitment given by an individual to repay the company’s outstanding dues if the company fails to fulfil its financial obligations. It provides additional security to the lender and may help the company obtain the required credit facilities.
However, an important taxation question arises:
Is GST applicable when a director provides a personal guarantee to a bank on behalf of their company? If yes, is GST payable at 18%, even when the director does not receive any payment or commission for providing the guarantee?
This question became particularly important after the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC) issued Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST dated 27 October 2023.
The circular clarified the GST treatment of personal guarantees provided by directors to banks and financial institutions for securing credit facilities for their companies.
Interestingly, the clarification distinguishes between the existence of a supply under GST and the valuation of that supply.
Although a personal guarantee provided by a director can constitute a supply of service under GST, its taxable value may be treated as zero when the director receives no consideration, subject to the conditions explained by CBIC.
On the other hand, where consideration is paid to the director in exceptional circumstances, GST may become payable on the taxable value of that consideration.
In this article, we explain the complete GST treatment of personal guarantees, the applicability of 18% GST, reverse charge mechanism, valuation provisions, relevant legal provisions, practical examples, documentation requirements, and common mistakes businesses should avoid.
1. What Is a Personal Guarantee Given by a Director to a Bank?
A personal guarantee is a legal commitment given by an individual to a lender to fulfil the financial obligations of another person or entity if the primary borrower defaults.
In the context of business financing, a director may provide a personal guarantee to a bank or financial institution to secure loans or credit facilities sanctioned to the company.
For example:
ABC Private Limited approaches a bank for a business loan of ₹1 crore.
The bank evaluates the company’s financial position, repayment capacity, business operations, and available security.
As an additional condition for sanctioning the loan, the bank asks one of the company’s directors to provide a personal guarantee.
The director signs the necessary guarantee documents and agrees to become personally liable in accordance with the guarantee terms if the company defaults.
In this situation:
- ABC Private Limited is the borrower.
- The bank is the lender.
- The director is the personal guarantor.
- The personal guarantee provides additional security to the bank.
The director may provide this guarantee without receiving any commission, brokerage, remuneration, or other payment from the company.
This is where the GST question becomes important.
2. Is Providing a Personal Guarantee Considered a Supply of Service Under GST?
Yes. According to CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST, providing a personal guarantee by a director to a bank or financial institution for securing credit facilities for the director’s company is treated as a supply of service, even when no consideration is received.
To understand this position, it is necessary to examine the provisions of the CGST Act, 2017.
Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017
Section 7 defines the scope of supply under GST.
Under Section 7(1)(c), activities specified in Schedule I are treated as supplies even when made without consideration, provided the relevant statutory conditions are fulfilled.
Entry 2 of Schedule I
Entry 2 of Schedule I covers the supply of goods or services between related persons or distinct persons, as specified under Section 25, when made in the course or furtherance of business, even if made without consideration.
Section 15 of the CGST Act
Explanation (a) to Section 15 provides that persons shall be deemed to be related where one of them is an officer or director of the other’s business.
Accordingly, a director and the company are treated as related persons for GST purposes.
Therefore, when a director provides a personal guarantee to a bank to secure credit facilities for the company, the activity is treated as a supply of service between related persons, even if the director does not receive any payment.
Important distinction: The fact that an activity qualifies as a supply does not automatically mean that GST must be paid on a positive taxable value.
The next question is how the value of this supply should be determined.
3. What Is CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST?
CBIC issued Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST on 27 October 2023 to clarify the GST treatment of personal guarantees and corporate guarantees.
The circular addresses two important issues:
- GST applicability on personal guarantees provided by directors to banks or financial institutions for their companies.
- GST applicability and valuation of corporate guarantees provided between related persons, including holding companies and subsidiaries.
For directors providing personal guarantees, the clarification is particularly significant because it addresses situations where the director does not receive any consideration.
The circular recognises that the director and company are related persons and that the guarantee can qualify as a supply under Schedule I.
However, it also considers the Reserve Bank of India’s guidelines regarding payment of commission or other consideration to directors for providing personal guarantees.
Consequently, where no consideration is payable or received, the open market value of the guarantee may be treated as zero, resulting in a zero taxable value.
This means that a supply may exist under GST law without any GST being payable because its taxable value is zero.
4. When Is 18% GST Applicable on a Personal Guarantee Given by a Director?
This is the most important question for directors and companies.
The applicability of GST depends primarily on whether any consideration is paid or provided to the director for furnishing the personal guarantee.
There are two broad situations.
Situation A: Director Provides a Personal Guarantee Without Any Consideration
Suppose a director provides a personal guarantee to a bank for securing a business loan sanctioned to the company.
The director does not receive:
- Guarantee commission.
- Brokerage.
- Professional fees.
- Separate remuneration.
- Any other direct or indirect benefit or consideration for providing the guarantee.
In this situation, CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST clarifies that the open market value of the transaction may be treated as zero.
Therefore, the taxable value of the personal guarantee is zero.
Result: No GST is payable on the personal guarantee in this situation.
Although the activity is considered a supply of service under Schedule I, there is no positive taxable value on which GST can be calculated.
Situation B: Director Receives Consideration for Providing a Personal Guarantee
Now consider a different situation.
A director provides a personal guarantee to a bank for securing a loan for the company.
However, the director receives remuneration or consideration for continuing to provide that guarantee.
In such cases, CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST clarifies that the taxable value shall be the remuneration or consideration provided to the guarantor.
GST may therefore become payable at the applicable rate.
For illustration, assuming the applicable GST rate is 18%:
| Particulars | Amount |
|---|---|
| Guarantee remuneration | ₹1,00,000 |
| GST rate (illustrative) | 18% |
| GST payable | ₹18,000 |
| Total tax-inclusive amount | ₹1,18,000 |
Result: GST at 18% may be applicable on the taxable consideration, subject to the applicable classification, rate notification, and other GST provisions.
However, it is important to understand the RBI restrictions governing payments for personal guarantees. Payment of guarantee commission to directors is generally prohibited under the relevant RBI guidelines, subject to the exceptional circumstances discussed later.
5. What Is the Role of RBI Guidelines in Determining GST on Personal Guarantees?
The Reserve Bank of India plays an important role in determining the treatment of consideration received by directors for providing personal guarantees.
The relevant reference is RBI Circular No. RBI/2021-22/121 dated 9 November 2021, particularly the provisions concerning personal guarantees of promoters, directors, other managerial personnel, and shareholders of borrowing concerns.
Under the relevant guidelines, banks should obtain personal guarantees only when warranted after examining the circumstances of the case.
The guidelines also address the payment of guarantee commission.
General Rule Under RBI Guidelines
The general principle is that a director should not use the system of providing personal guarantees as a source of income from the company.
Where personal guarantees are warranted, banks should obtain an undertaking from the borrowing company and guarantors that no consideration, whether by way of commission, brokerage fees, or any other form, will be paid or received directly or indirectly.
This restriction is important for understanding why CBIC considers the open market value to be zero in ordinary cases where no consideration is payable.
Exceptional Circumstances
RBI guidelines recognise certain exceptional circumstances.
For example, an existing guarantor may no longer be connected with the management of the company, but the continuation of that person’s guarantee may still be considered essential.
This may happen where:
- The guarantee of the new management is unavailable.
- The guarantee of the new management is considered inadequate.
- The existing guarantor’s continued support is essential for the borrowing arrangement.
- The applicable RBI conditions permit remuneration to be paid.
In such exceptional cases, remuneration may be permitted.
CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST specifically addresses these situations and clarifies that the taxable value shall be the remuneration or consideration provided to the guarantor.
Therefore, the GST position must be examined together with the RBI guidelines and the actual contractual and financial arrangements.
6. Why Is the Taxable Value Zero When No Consideration Is Received?
A common question is:
If Section 7 treats the personal guarantee as a supply even without consideration, why is GST not payable?
The answer lies in the valuation provisions under GST.
Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, 2017
Rule 28 provides the valuation mechanism for supplies between related persons and distinct persons, other than supplies made through an agent.
The general principle under Rule 28 is that the value of such supplies is determined with reference to their open market value, subject to the prescribed valuation rules and alternatives.
In the case of personal guarantees provided by directors, CBIC considered the relevant RBI guidelines.
Since the director generally cannot receive commission, brokerage fees, or other consideration for providing the guarantee, there is no ordinary payment-based open market value for such a transaction.
Accordingly, CBIC clarified that the open market value may be treated as zero.
The taxable value can therefore be treated as zero.
Understanding the Difference Between Supply and Taxable Value
Consider the following:
| Particulars | Position |
|---|---|
| Director provides personal guarantee | Yes |
| Director and company are related persons | Yes |
| Activity qualifies as a supply | Yes |
| Consideration received | Nil |
| Open market value, as clarified by CBIC | Zero |
| Taxable value | Zero |
| GST payable | Nil |
This distinction is extremely important.
Businesses should not conclude that every activity treated as a supply under GST automatically results in a GST liability.
The valuation provisions must also be examined.
7. Is GST Payable Under Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM)?
Yes, the reverse charge mechanism is relevant when a director provides a taxable service to the company in the capacity of a director.
Notification No. 13/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017, specifies services supplied by a director of a company or body corporate to that company or body corporate under reverse charge.
Under the relevant entry, the company is responsible for paying the applicable GST under RCM.
This means that the tax liability is generally on the company receiving the director’s service, rather than on the director as the supplier, when the relevant RCM entry applies.
Who Is Responsible for Paying GST?
| Particulars | Responsibility |
|---|---|
| Service provider | Director |
| Recipient | Company |
| GST payment mechanism | Reverse Charge Mechanism |
| Person responsible for payment | Company |
| Applicable rate where taxable | Generally 18%, subject to classification and rate notification |
What Happens When the Taxable Value Is Zero?
The existence of an RCM entry does not create a positive tax liability when the taxable value itself is zero.
For example:
A director provides a personal guarantee to the bank without receiving any consideration.
The activity qualifies as a supply under Schedule I, but the taxable value is zero under the clarification in Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST.
Therefore, there is no GST amount payable under RCM on that zero-valued supply.
What Happens When Consideration Is Received?
If consideration is payable in an exceptional case and the service is supplied by the director in the capacity of a director, the company must examine the RCM provisions and discharge the applicable GST accordingly.
It is also important to note that Circular No. 13/2023-GST clarifies the distinction between services supplied by directors in their official capacity and services supplied in their private or personal capacity.
The RCM treatment should therefore be determined by examining the actual nature and capacity in which the service is supplied.
8. Practical Examples of GST on Personal Guarantees by Directors
Let us understand the provisions through practical business situations.
Example 1: Director Provides a Personal Guarantee Without Receiving Any Payment
ABC Private Limited obtains a business loan of ₹50 lakh from a bank.
The bank requires its managing director to provide a personal guarantee.
The director signs the guarantee documents but does not receive any commission, brokerage, fees, or other consideration.
GST treatment:
- The director and company are related persons.
- The guarantee qualifies as a supply of service under Schedule I.
- No consideration is received.
- The relevant RBI restrictions prohibit ordinary payment of commission for such guarantees.
- The open market value may be treated as zero under CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST.
GST payable: Nil.
Example 2: Director Receives Guarantee Remuneration in an Exceptional Case
XYZ Limited has an existing personal guarantee from a former director.
The former director is no longer involved in the management of the company. However, the bank considers the continuation of the existing guarantee essential because the guarantee of the new management is unavailable or inadequate.
Assume remuneration of ₹2,00,000 is lawfully payable under the applicable RBI conditions.
For illustration, assuming GST at 18%:
| Particulars | Amount |
|---|---|
| Remuneration | ₹2,00,000 |
| GST at 18% | ₹36,000 |
| Total | ₹2,36,000 |
The company must examine the RCM provisions and applicable tax treatment.
GST payable: ₹36,000, assuming the stated consideration is the taxable value and 18% is the applicable rate.
Example 3: Director Provides a Guarantee for Multiple Credit Facilities
A director provides personal guarantees to two different banks for the company’s working capital and term loan facilities.
The director does not receive any separate payment for providing or continuing the guarantees.
The mere fact that the director provides multiple guarantees or that the guaranteed loan amount is substantial does not automatically create a taxable value equal to a percentage of the total guarantee amount.
The valuation must be determined under Rule 28 and the CBIC clarification.
Where the conditions for the zero-value treatment are satisfied, the taxable value may remain zero.
Example 4: Company Pays Indirect Consideration
Suppose a company does not directly pay a guarantee commission to its director.
However, the company provides a separate financial benefit that is specifically linked to the personal guarantee.
The tax authorities may examine whether this arrangement represents indirect consideration for providing the guarantee.
The actual substance of the transaction is important.
A company should not assume that the absence of an invoice or a payment described as guarantee commission automatically establishes a zero-value transaction.
The relevant agreements, board records, payment arrangements, and applicable RBI requirements should be reviewed.
9. Is GST Calculated on the Entire Loan Amount or Guarantee Amount?
One of the biggest misconceptions concerning GST on personal guarantees is that GST must be calculated on the entire loan amount or guaranteed amount.
This is not the valuation approach prescribed by CBIC for personal guarantees provided by directors.
For personal guarantees, Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST clarifies that:
- Where no consideration is payable, the open market value may be treated as zero.
- Where remuneration or consideration is provided in an applicable exceptional case, the taxable value shall be that remuneration or consideration.
Therefore, the taxable value is not automatically 1% of the loan amount or the guaranteed amount.
Example
A director provides a personal guarantee for a bank loan of ₹5 crore.
The director receives no consideration for the guarantee.
The taxable value should not automatically be calculated as:
₹5 crore × 1% = ₹5 lakh.
Instead, the valuation principles under Rule 28 and the specific clarification in Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST must be applied.
If the conditions for zero valuation are satisfied, the taxable value may be zero.
Important: The special valuation mechanism introduced for corporate guarantees under Rule 28(2) should not be confused with the valuation of personal guarantees provided by directors.
10. Difference Between Personal Guarantee and Corporate Guarantee Under GST
Although personal guarantees and corporate guarantees are both used to secure financial facilities, their GST valuation treatment is different.
Understanding this distinction is essential because businesses often apply the corporate guarantee valuation formula incorrectly to personal guarantees.
Personal Guarantee
A personal guarantee is provided by an individual, such as a director or promoter, in their personal capacity to secure the company’s borrowing.
The individual becomes personally responsible in accordance with the guarantee agreement if the borrower defaults.
For GST purposes, CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST clarifies that a personal guarantee by a director to a bank is treated as a supply of service to the company.
Where no consideration is payable, its taxable value may be treated as zero.
Corporate Guarantee
A corporate guarantee is provided by one company or other eligible related person to secure the borrowing obligations of another company.
For example, a holding company may provide a corporate guarantee to a bank for a loan taken by its subsidiary.
The valuation of qualifying corporate guarantees is governed by the special provisions under Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules.
Key Differences
| Particulars | Personal Guarantee | Corporate Guarantee |
|---|---|---|
| Guarantor | Individual director | Company or other eligible related person |
| Beneficiary of credit facility | Company | Related company |
| Relevant CBIC clarification | Circular 204/16/2023-GST | Circular 204/16/2023-GST |
| Valuation provision | Rule 28, as clarified by CBIC | Rule 28(2), where applicable |
| No-consideration treatment | Open market value may be zero | Special prescribed valuation applies |
| Automatic 1% valuation | No | Rule 28(2) contains a prescribed 1% annual valuation mechanism, subject to its terms |
Important Clarification Regarding the 1% Valuation Rule
Rule 28(2) was introduced through Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax dated 26 October 2023.
It provides a special valuation mechanism for qualifying corporate guarantees.
Under this provision, the taxable value is generally determined using 1% of the amount guaranteed or the actual consideration, whichever is higher, subject to the precise wording and applicable provisions of the rule.
However, CBIC specifically clarified that Rule 28(2) does not apply to personal guarantees provided by directors to banks or financial institutions for securing credit facilities for their companies.
Therefore, applying the corporate guarantee formula directly to a director’s personal guarantee would be incorrect.
11. Is 18% GST Applicable to All Director Guarantees?
No.
It is important to distinguish the GST rate from the question of whether a positive taxable value exists.
A rate of 18% does not mean every director who signs a personal guarantee must pay 18% GST on the guaranteed amount.
The applicable tax treatment depends on:
- Whether the activity qualifies as a supply.
- Whether the director and company are related persons.
- Whether the service is provided in the capacity of a director.
- Whether any consideration is received or payable.
- How the taxable value is determined under Rule 28.
- Whether the applicable reverse charge provisions apply.
- The relevant classification and GST rate notification.
Where a taxable value exists and the applicable rate is 18%, GST may be payable at that rate.
Where the value is zero under the specific CBIC clarification, the GST payable is also zero.
12. What Documents Should a Company Maintain?
Companies should maintain appropriate documentation to support the GST treatment adopted for personal guarantees.
This is particularly important where the company claims that the taxable value of the director’s personal guarantee is zero.
The following documents may be useful:
1. Personal Guarantee Agreement
Maintain a copy of the guarantee agreement executed between the director and the bank.
The document should clearly identify the borrower, guarantor, bank, credit facility, and relevant guarantee conditions.
2. Loan Sanction Letter
Maintain the bank’s loan sanction letter or credit facility approval letter.
This helps establish that the personal guarantee was provided for securing credit facilities granted to the company.
3. Board Resolution
Maintain the relevant board resolution or corporate records concerning the borrowing arrangement and personal guarantee, where applicable.
4. Declaration of No Consideration
Where appropriate, maintain a written declaration confirming that no guarantee commission, brokerage, fees, or other direct or indirect consideration has been paid or provided for the personal guarantee.
5. Accounting Records
Review the company’s books of accounts to ensure that no amount has been recorded as guarantee commission, guarantee fees, or any other payment specifically linked to the personal guarantee.
6. RBI Compliance Documentation
Maintain the relevant undertaking and supporting documentation required under applicable RBI guidelines and the bank’s loan conditions.
7. GST Working Paper
Prepare a short internal GST note explaining:
- The nature of the guarantee.
- The relationship between the director and company.
- The applicable provisions of Section 7 and Schedule I.
- The valuation approach under Rule 28.
- The application of CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST.
- The reason for adopting a zero taxable value, where applicable.
Proper documentation can help the company explain its position during GST audits, assessments, and departmental enquiries.
13. Common Mistakes Companies Make Regarding GST on Personal Guarantees
Businesses should avoid the following common mistakes.
Mistake 1: Applying 18% GST on the Entire Guaranteed Amount
The guarantee amount and the taxable value of the service are not automatically the same.
The applicable valuation rules must be examined.
Mistake 2: Applying the 1% Rule to Personal Guarantees
The 1% valuation mechanism under Rule 28(2) concerns qualifying corporate guarantees.
It does not automatically apply to personal guarantees provided by directors.
Mistake 3: Assuming That No Supply Exists Because No Money Is Received
Schedule I recognises certain supplies between related persons even without consideration.
Therefore, the absence of consideration does not necessarily mean that no supply exists.
Mistake 4: Ignoring Reverse Charge Mechanism
Where a director provides a taxable service to the company in the capacity of a director, the applicable RCM provisions must be examined.
The company should not automatically assume that the director is responsible for paying GST.
Mistake 5: Ignoring Indirect Consideration
Companies should examine whether any financial benefit, payment, or arrangement represents direct or indirect consideration for providing the guarantee.
The actual commercial substance of the arrangement matters.
Mistake 6: Confusing Personal Guarantees With Corporate Guarantees
The two arrangements have different valuation treatments.
The provisions applicable to corporate guarantees should not be mechanically applied to personal guarantees.
Mistake 7: Ignoring RBI Restrictions
The GST analysis must be consistent with the applicable RBI guidelines governing personal guarantees and guarantee commission.
14. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Is GST applicable on a personal guarantee given by a director to a bank?
Providing a personal guarantee by a director to a bank for securing credit facilities for the company is treated as a supply of service under GST, even without consideration. However, where no consideration is payable or received, the taxable value may be treated as zero under CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST. Consequently, no GST is payable in such circumstances.
Q2. Is 18% GST payable on a director’s personal guarantee?
GST at the applicable rate, generally 18% for the relevant taxable service classification, may be payable where a positive taxable value exists. However, where no consideration is payable and the zero-value clarification applies, no GST is payable.
Q3. Is GST payable if the director does not receive any commission?
Generally, no GST is payable where the director receives no consideration, directly or indirectly, and the conditions explained in Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST are satisfied.
Q4. Is GST applicable on a personal guarantee of ₹1 crore?
The GST liability is not automatically calculated on the ₹1 crore guarantee amount. The taxable value must be determined under Rule 28 and the relevant CBIC clarification.
Q5. Is the 1% valuation rule applicable to personal guarantees?
No. The special valuation mechanism under Rule 28(2) applies to qualifying corporate guarantees. CBIC has specifically clarified that it does not apply to personal guarantees provided by directors.
Q6. Who pays GST on a personal guarantee provided by a director?
Where the director supplies the taxable service to the company in the capacity of a director, the company generally pays GST under the reverse charge mechanism in terms of Notification No. 13/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
Q7. What happens if a former director continues to provide a personal guarantee?
CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST specifically addresses exceptional situations where an existing guarantor is no longer involved in management but the continuation of the guarantee is considered essential. Where remuneration or consideration is provided, that amount is considered the taxable value.
Q8. Does the company need to pay RCM when the taxable value is zero?
Where the taxable value is zero under the relevant clarification, there is no GST amount payable on that supply. The company should nevertheless maintain supporting documentation and examine the applicable return and record-keeping requirements.
Q9. Is GST applicable if a director provides a guarantee for multiple loans?
The number of loans or the aggregate guaranteed amount does not independently determine the taxable value. The valuation principles and actual consideration must be examined.
Q10. Does Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST apply to corporate guarantees?
Yes, the circular addresses both personal and corporate guarantees. However, their valuation mechanisms are different. Corporate guarantees are subject to the special Rule 28(2) provisions where applicable.
Q11. Can a director receive guarantee commission from the company?
Under the relevant RBI guidelines, guarantee commission is generally not permitted in ordinary circumstances. Exceptional cases may permit remuneration subject to the applicable RBI conditions.
Q12. Is GST payable by the bank or the company?
For services supplied by a director to the company in the capacity of a director, the company is generally responsible for paying GST under RCM. The bank is the beneficiary of the guarantee, but that does not automatically make it the recipient responsible for the director’s service under this specific RCM entry.
15. Important Legal Provisions and Notifications to Refer To
For a proper understanding of GST on personal guarantees, the following legal provisions and official clarifications should be considered:
| Legal reference | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Section 7 of the CGST Act, 2017 | Definition and scope of supply |
| Schedule I, Entry 2 | Supply between related persons without consideration |
| Section 15 of the CGST Act, 2017 | Related persons and valuation framework |
| Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, 2017 | Valuation of supplies between related persons |
| Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, 2017 | Special valuation of qualifying corporate guarantees |
| Notification No. 13/2017-Central Tax (Rate) | Reverse charge on services supplied by directors |
| Circular No. 13/2023-GST | Director services supplied in official versus personal capacity |
| Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST | Clarification on personal and corporate guarantees |
| Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax | Insertion of the special corporate guarantee valuation provision |
| RBI Circular No. RBI/2021-22/121 | Guidelines concerning personal guarantees of directors and other persons |
16. Conclusion: When Is 18% GST Actually Payable on a Director’s Personal Guarantee?
The GST treatment of personal guarantees provided by directors should be understood by separating three important concepts: supply, valuation, and tax payment.
Under Section 7 read with Schedule I of the CGST Act, providing a personal guarantee by a director to secure credit facilities for the company is treated as a supply of service between related persons, even when no consideration is received.
However, CBIC Circular No. 204/16/2023-GST dated 27 October 2023 clarifies that where no consideration is payable or received, taking into account the applicable RBI restrictions, the open market value may be treated as zero.
Consequently, the taxable value may be zero and no GST is payable in such circumstances.
Where remuneration or consideration is provided in an exceptional situation permitted under the relevant RBI guidelines, the taxable value is the remuneration or consideration provided to the guarantor. GST may then be payable at the applicable rate, generally 18% for the relevant taxable service classification, with the company examining its liability under the reverse charge mechanism.
It is equally important to remember that the 1% valuation mechanism applicable to qualifying corporate guarantees under Rule 28(2) should not be applied to personal guarantees provided by directors.
The key takeaway: A director providing a personal guarantee does not automatically trigger 18% GST on the guaranteed loan amount. The actual consideration and the applicable valuation provisions determine the GST liability.
Need Professional Assistance With GST Compliance?
Understanding GST provisions is important, but applying them correctly to your company’s actual financial and contractual arrangements is equally important.
At CleverCoins, we help businesses navigate GST compliance, GST return filing, taxation matters, and related financial and regulatory requirements.
If your company has received a GST query concerning director guarantees, reverse charge mechanism, or valuation of related-party transactions, professional review can help you identify the applicable provisions and maintain appropriate documentation.
Connect with CleverCoins for GST and taxation assistance.
Website: https://clevercoins.org/
Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational and educational purposes. GST treatment depends on the specific facts, contractual arrangements, applicable notifications, and legal provisions. Readers should obtain professional advice before taking a tax position. The legal references and rate applicability should be verified against the latest applicable notifications and amendments before publication or implementation.
Related posts:
PM Kaushal Vikas Yojana 4.0 for MSME Employees: The Complete Guide to Free Skill Training, RPL Certi...
RAMP Scheme Cluster Development: How Industrial Clusters Get Liveability Grants
ONDC Seller Incentive Scheme 2025: How Small Sellers Get Free Delivery Support
GST on Corporate Guarantee to Subsidiary MSME: New Valuation Rule 2025 – Complete Guide to Rule 28(2...
NSIC Single Point Registration Scheme: How MSMEs Get Tender Benefits
MSME Competitive (LEAN) Scheme: How Indian Enterprises Can Claim 90% Government Support for Lean Cer...
PM-DAKSH Yojana for MSME Artisans: Free Training with Stipend 2025
PMEGP Urban vs Rural Subsidy 2025: The Ultimate Guide to Funding, Eligibility, and Location Strategy...
Coir Vikas Yojana 2025: Government Schemes for Coir MSMEs in Kerala & Tamil Nadu
Procurement and Marketing Support Scheme: Reimbursement for MSME Trade Fairs – Complete Guide
Related posts:
Self Reliant India (SRI) Fund: Rs 50,000 Cr Equity Infusion for MSMEs Explained
Credit Guarantee Scheme for Exporters (CGSE): New 2025 Scheme for MSME Exporters
Agri Infra Fund for Food Processing MSMEs: Complete Guide to 3% Interest Subvention, Eligibility, Benefits and Application Process
GST on Corporate Guarantee to Subsidiary MSME: New Valuation Rule 2025 – Complete Guide to Rule 28(2), 1% GST Valuation and ITC



