GST on Secondment of Employees: Tax Implications for MSME Group Companies
Introduction
In today’s competitive business environment, many businesses operate through multiple companies, subsidiaries, holding companies and associated enterprises. This structure is particularly common among Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) that are expanding their operations, entering new markets or establishing specialised business divisions.
One common practice adopted by such business groups is employee secondment.
Under an employee secondment arrangement, one company temporarily assigns or deputes its employees to another company within the same business group. The employee may work with the receiving company for a specified period, perform managerial or operational responsibilities and contribute to its business activities.
For example, a parent company may appoint a finance manager to supervise the accounts department of its subsidiary. Similarly, a manufacturing company may depute technical employees to a group company’s factory, or a holding company may assign senior management personnel to oversee the operations of multiple subsidiaries.
Although these arrangements are commercially convenient, they can create important Goods and Services Tax (GST) implications.
The most common question is:
Is GST applicable when one group company deputes its employees to another group company and recovers their salary costs?
The answer is not always straightforward.
The GST treatment depends on the actual employment relationship, the nature of the secondment agreement, the responsibilities of the respective companies, the manner of salary payment, the degree of control exercised over the employees and the substance of the arrangement.
The Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise and Service Tax v. Northern Operating Systems Private Limited (2022) has made employee secondment an important indirect taxation issue. Subsequently, CBIC issued Instruction No. 05/2023-GST dated 13 December 2023, clarifying that the judgment should not be mechanically applied to every secondment arrangement.
For MSME group companies, understanding these principles is essential to avoid unnecessary GST liabilities, interest, penalties and disputes.
This article explains the GST implications of employee secondment in India, including domestic and international arrangements, salary reimbursements, cross-charge, related-party transactions, input tax credit and practical compliance measures.
1. What Is Employee Secondment?
Employee secondment refers to the temporary assignment of an employee from one organisation to another organisation for performing specific duties or responsibilities.
In a group company structure, secondment generally takes place when an employee of one group company is deputed to another group company to support its business operations.
The employee may work at the receiving company’s premises, report to its management, participate in its business activities and perform duties assigned by its authorised personnel.
However, the original employer and the receiving company may have different contractual responsibilities.
For example:
- Company A is the holding company of Company B.
- Company A employs a qualified finance professional.
- Company B requires an experienced finance manager.
- Company A temporarily deputes the employee to Company B.
- The employee works under Company B’s operational supervision.
- Company A may continue processing the employee’s salary.
- Company B reimburses the salary and related employment expenses to Company A.
This arrangement is commonly referred to as employee secondment.
Important characteristics of secondment
An employee secondment arrangement may involve:
- Temporary deployment of an employee.
- An agreement between the original employer and the receiving company.
- A defined secondment period.
- Allocation of responsibilities between both companies.
- Salary payment by the original employer or receiving company.
- Reimbursement of employment-related expenses.
- Operational supervision by the receiving company.
- Provisions concerning termination, repatriation and continuation of employment.
Not every secondment arrangement contains all these characteristics. The legal and commercial substance of the arrangement must be examined individually.
2. Why Is Employee Secondment Important for MSME Group Companies?
Employee secondment is particularly useful for MSMEs because it allows businesses to share specialised employees without permanently transferring their employment.
Consider an MSME business group consisting of three companies:
- Company A: Manufacturing business.
- Company B: Trading business.
- Company C: Logistics and distribution business.
Instead of hiring separate finance managers, HR managers and compliance professionals for every company, the group may use experienced employees from Company A to support the operations of Companies B and C.
This arrangement offers several commercial advantages.
A. Reduction in recruitment expenses
MSMEs often operate with limited financial resources. Recruiting senior professionals for every group entity can increase operating expenses.
Secondment allows businesses to utilise existing employees and avoid unnecessary recruitment costs.
B. Better utilisation of skilled employees
A group company may have experienced professionals whose expertise can benefit multiple entities.
Secondment allows the group to utilise this expertise efficiently.
C. Centralised management
Businesses may centralise finance, accounting, HR, taxation and administrative functions while maintaining separate legal entities.
D. Operational flexibility
Employees can be assigned to specific companies depending on business requirements.
E. Business expansion
When an MSME establishes a new subsidiary or enters another geographical market, experienced employees can be deputed to support the new business.
However, while secondment may be commercially beneficial, businesses must carefully evaluate its GST consequences.
3. Understanding the Legal Framework of GST on Employee Secondment
The GST treatment of employee secondment primarily revolves around the following provisions of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act):
- Section 7: Scope of supply.
- Section 9: Levy and collection of GST.
- Section 15: Value of taxable supply.
- Section 16: Eligibility and conditions for input tax credit.
- Section 17: Apportionment and blocked credits.
- Section 25: Registration and distinct persons.
- Schedule I: Activities treated as supply even without consideration.
- Schedule III: Activities treated neither as supply of goods nor supply of services.
Understanding these provisions helps determine whether the secondment arrangement creates a taxable supply.
3.1 Section 7 – Scope of Supply
Section 7 defines the scope of supply under GST.
Generally, GST applies to supplies of goods or services made for consideration in the course or furtherance of business, subject to the statutory provisions.
However, certain transactions listed in Schedule I are treated as supplies even when consideration is absent.
This is particularly important for group companies because transactions between related persons may attract GST even when no separate payment is made.
3.2 Schedule III – Services by an Employee to an Employer
Entry 1 of Schedule III provides that:
“Services by an employee to the employer in the course of or in relation to his employment” shall be treated as neither a supply of goods nor a supply of services.
This provision is the starting point for analysing employee secondment.
Where an individual provides services to their employer in the course of employment, the services are outside the scope of GST.
Consequently, ordinary salary paid by an employer to its employee is not subject to GST.
However, the important question is:
Who is the actual employer for GST purposes?
If Company A deputes its employee to Company B, it is necessary to determine whether the arrangement represents genuine employment with Company B or a supply of manpower or other services by Company A to Company B.
The answer depends on the facts and contractual arrangements.
3.3 Schedule I – Supply Between Related Persons
Schedule I includes supplies made between related persons in the course or furtherance of business, even where such supplies are made without consideration, subject to the statutory exceptions.
This becomes important where two group companies are legally separate entities.
For example, Company A and Company B may have common shareholders, common directors or a parent-subsidiary relationship.
If Company A provides employee deployment or management services to Company B, the transaction may constitute a taxable supply between related persons.
The absence of a separate service fee does not automatically eliminate GST liability.
However, the transaction must first qualify as a supply under the applicable provisions.
4. Supreme Court Judgment: Northern Operating Systems Case
One of the most significant judicial developments concerning employee secondment is the Supreme Court’s judgment in:
Commissioner of Customs, Central Excise and Service Tax, Bangalore (Adjudication) v. Northern Operating Systems Private Limited (2022).
The judgment was delivered on 19 May 2022.
Although the case concerned the erstwhile Service Tax regime, its reasoning is highly relevant to understanding secondment arrangements under GST.
4.1 Background of the case
Northern Operating Systems Private Limited (NOS) was an Indian company receiving employees from overseas group entities.
These employees were deputed to India to perform business activities for NOS.
The overseas entities continued to have contractual and administrative involvement in relation to the employees.
The arrangement involved several features, including:
- Employees being selected or deputed by overseas group companies.
- Salary-related payments being made through the overseas entities.
- Reimbursement of employment costs by the Indian company.
- The employees performing functions for the Indian company.
- Employment-related policies and arrangements continuing to involve the overseas entities.
The department alleged that the overseas group entities were supplying manpower services to the Indian company.
The dispute concerned whether the arrangement represented an employer-employee relationship or a taxable service of manpower supply.
4.2 Supreme Court’s decision
The Supreme Court examined the overall substance of the arrangement rather than relying exclusively on the fact that employees worked under the Indian company’s operational supervision.
The Court held, on the facts of that case, that the overseas group entities were supplying manpower services to the Indian company and Service Tax was payable.
An important aspect of the judgment was that operational control exercised by the receiving company did not, by itself, conclusively establish that the receiving company was the actual employer.
The broader contractual and employment arrangements also had to be considered.
4.3 Why is the judgment relevant under GST?
The principles discussed in the NOS judgment are relevant because GST also distinguishes between:
- Services provided by an employee to an employer; and
- Services supplied by one business entity to another business entity.
If the original employer is effectively providing manpower or personnel deployment services to the receiving company, GST may become applicable.
However, the judgment does not establish that every employee secondment arrangement is automatically taxable.
5. CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023-GST: Important Clarification
Following the Supreme Court judgment, several businesses expressed concerns regarding the possible GST consequences of secondment arrangements.
CBIC issued Instruction No. 05/2023-GST dated 13 December 2023.
This instruction is particularly important for MSMEs and group companies.
5.1 Secondment arrangements must be examined individually
CBIC clarified that different secondment arrangements may have different tax implications.
The nature of the contract and its terms and conditions must be examined before determining GST liability.
The instruction specifically states that the NOS judgment should not be mechanically applied in all cases.
5.2 No single factor determines GST liability
Businesses should not rely exclusively on any one of the following factors:
- Whether salary is paid by the original employer.
- Whether salary is paid by the receiving company.
- Whether salary is reimbursed.
- Whether the employee remains on the original company’s payroll.
- Whether the employee works from the receiving company’s office.
- Whether the receiving company supervises daily activities.
These factors should be evaluated together.
5.3 Section 74 cannot be invoked mechanically
CBIC also clarified that Section 74(1) of the CGST Act can be invoked only where there is material evidence of fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with the intention to evade tax.
Mere non-payment of GST does not, by itself, justify invoking Section 74(1).
This is an important safeguard for businesses facing secondment-related investigations.
Practical takeaway: MSMEs should maintain proper documentation demonstrating the actual nature of their secondment arrangements instead of assuming that every salary reimbursement is taxable or that every secondment is exempt.
6. Is GST Applicable on Salary Reimbursement Between Group Companies?
This is one of the most frequently asked questions by MSME owners and finance professionals.
The answer depends on the underlying arrangement.
Situation A: Genuine Employer-Employee Relationship
Suppose Company A deputes an employee to Company B.
After examining the contractual and operational arrangements, it is established that:
- Company B is the genuine employer during the relevant period.
- The employee works under Company B’s employment terms.
- Company B has the relevant rights and responsibilities of an employer.
- Company A merely facilitates salary payment as an administrative arrangement.
- The amount recovered by Company A represents a genuine settlement of an amount paid on behalf of Company B.
In such circumstances, the employee’s services to Company B may fall within Schedule III.
The salary payment itself would not be treated as a taxable supply merely because Company A processed or initially paid it.
However, any separate service provided by Company A must be examined independently.
Situation B: Manpower Supply by Company A
Suppose Company A continues to employ the individual and deputes the employee to Company B.
Company A retains the substantive employment relationship and makes the employee available to Company B under a contractual arrangement.
Company B pays Company A the salary cost, together with administrative charges or a service fee.
In such circumstances, the arrangement may constitute a taxable manpower supply or other personnel-related service.
GST may therefore become applicable.
Situation C: Reimbursement of Salary Without Clear Documentation
Suppose Company A pays the salary and Company B reimburses the amount without any detailed agreement.
The companies merely describe the payment as a reimbursement.
This creates a potential GST risk.
The absence of a profit margin does not automatically mean that the transaction is outside GST.
The department may examine whether Company A is actually supplying manpower or other services to Company B.
Important: The accounting description of a transaction does not determine its GST treatment. Its actual legal and commercial substance is more important.
7. Difference Between Salary Payment and Manpower Supply
Businesses must distinguish between salary paid by an employer and consideration paid for manpower services.
| Particulars | Employee salary | Manpower supply |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Employment compensation | Supply of services |
| Recipient | Employee | Business customer |
| Employment relationship | Employer and employee | Service provider and recipient |
| GST treatment | Outside GST under Schedule III | Generally taxable, subject to classification and applicable exemptions |
| Invoice | Salary records and payroll documents | GST tax invoice, where applicable |
| Payment | Salary payment | Service consideration |
| Compliance | Payroll and employment compliance | GST invoicing and returns |
For example, when Company A pays its own employee a monthly salary of ₹60,000, GST does not apply to that salary.
However, if Company A supplies the employee’s services to Company B under a manpower supply agreement, the amount charged to Company B may be taxable.
The fact that the amount charged is equal to the employee’s salary does not automatically change the nature of the supply.
8. Domestic Secondment Versus International Secondment
Employee secondment arrangements generally fall into two categories.
8.1 Domestic Employee Secondment
Domestic secondment occurs when an employee is deputed between two Indian companies or between group entities operating in India.
For example:
- Company A is registered in Maharashtra.
- Company B is registered in Gujarat.
- Company A deputes an employee to Company B.
- Company B reimburses the employment costs.
The GST implications depend on whether the transaction represents an employment arrangement or a supply of services.
Where taxable, the applicable place-of-supply and inter-State or intra-State rules must be examined.
8.2 International Employee Secondment
International secondment occurs when an overseas parent company or foreign group company deputes an employee to an Indian group company.
For example:
- A Singapore-based parent company employs a technical expert.
- The expert is deputed to an Indian subsidiary.
- The Indian subsidiary reimburses the salary and related expenses.
- The overseas company remains involved in employment administration.
In such situations, the arrangement may constitute an import of services.
If the foreign company is treated as supplying manpower or other services to the Indian company, the Indian recipient may be liable to pay Integrated GST under the reverse charge mechanism, subject to the applicable import-of-services conditions.
8.3 Import of Services: Important Conditions
Under Section 2(11) of the IGST Act, an import of services generally requires:
- The supplier of the service to be located outside India.
- The recipient of the service to be located in India.
- The place of supply to be in India.
Where these conditions are satisfied, the transaction may constitute an import of services.
Section 5(3) of the IGST Act, read with the applicable reverse charge notification, must then be examined.
The Indian company should evaluate the following:
- Whether the overseas entity is supplying manpower or another service.
- Whether the transaction represents genuine employment.
- Whether the overseas entity and Indian recipient are related.
- Whether the place of supply is in India.
- Whether GST under reverse charge is applicable.
- Whether the Indian company is eligible for corresponding input tax credit.
A foreign secondment arrangement should never be treated as automatically exempt merely because the payment is described as salary reimbursement.
9. GST Rate on Employee Secondment
Where the arrangement is classified as a taxable manpower supply or another taxable service, the applicable GST rate depends on the relevant service classification and prevailing rate notification.
Manpower supply and similar staffing services are commonly taxable at 18%, subject to the applicable classification and any specific exemption or alternative treatment.
For an inter-State domestic supply, IGST may apply.
For an intra-State supply, CGST and SGST may apply.
For imports of services, IGST is generally relevant under the reverse charge mechanism where the statutory conditions are met.
Businesses should verify the correct Service Accounting Code (SAC), applicable notification and rate before issuing an invoice or paying tax.
10. GST on Transactions Between Related Group Companies
A critical consideration for MSMEs is that two companies belonging to the same business group are not necessarily treated as one entity under GST.
For example:
- ABC Private Limited owns 100% of XYZ Private Limited.
- Both companies have common directors.
- Both companies operate from the same business premises.
- Both companies share finance and HR employees.
Despite their common ownership, they remain separate legal persons.
If one company supplies taxable services to another related company, GST may apply.
10.1 Related Persons Under GST
The explanation to Section 15 of the CGST Act provides the framework for identifying related persons.
Relationships may arise through ownership, control, management, employment and other specified connections.
Therefore, group companies should not assume that transactions between them are automatically outside GST.
10.2 Supply Without Consideration
Schedule I treats certain supplies between related persons made in the course or furtherance of business as supplies even without consideration.
This means that a group company providing services to another related entity may attract GST even if it does not recover a separate service fee.
However, a transaction must still satisfy the statutory conditions for supply.
10.3 Separate Legal Entity Versus Distinct Person
This distinction is extremely important.
Related companies: Two separately incorporated companies may be related persons.
Distinct persons: Separate GST registrations obtained by the same legal entity under Section 25(4) or 25(5) are treated as distinct persons.
For example, a company having GST registrations in Maharashtra and Karnataka is treated as having distinct persons for GST purposes.
Transactions between these registrations can be taxable even without consideration under Schedule I.
The treatment of related companies and distinct GST registrations should not be confused.
11. Cross-Charge of Employee Costs Between Group Companies
Cross-charge refers to the allocation or charging of costs associated with services provided by one GST registration or business entity to another.
In MSME group structures, cross-charge commonly arises where employees perform services benefiting multiple group entities.
For example:
- Company A has a central finance team.
- The finance team supports Companies B and C.
- Company A incurs employee salaries and administrative expenses.
- The other companies benefit from the services.
- Company A allocates the relevant costs to Companies B and C.
Whether GST applies depends on the legal structure and the nature of the arrangement.
Example: Cross-Charge Between Separate GST Registrations
ABC Limited has the following registrations:
- Maharashtra GSTIN.
- Gujarat GSTIN.
- Karnataka GSTIN.
The Maharashtra office manages centralised HR and finance functions.
Employees located at the Maharashtra office provide services to the Gujarat and Karnataka registrations.
Since these registrations are distinct persons under GST, the services supplied between them may be taxable under Schedule I.
The value of supply must be determined under Rule 28 of the CGST Rules.
Example: Cross-Charge Between Separate Group Companies
ABC Limited and XYZ Limited are separately incorporated companies.
ABC provides finance and management services to XYZ.
If the arrangement constitutes a taxable supply between related persons, GST may apply even without a separate payment.
This is different from an ordinary internal cost allocation within one legal entity.
Does Cross-Charge Automatically Apply to Every Salary Expense?
No.
Businesses must first establish that a service is being supplied between the relevant taxable persons.
The mere existence of common employees, common ownership or salary allocation does not independently determine the tax treatment.
12. Valuation of Secondment Services Under GST
Once a transaction is identified as a taxable supply, the next question is how its value should be determined.
Section 15 of the CGST Act and the applicable valuation rules provide the relevant framework.
12.1 Rule 28 – Supply Between Related or Distinct Persons
Rule 28 applies to the valuation of supplies between distinct persons under Section 25 and related persons, other than through an agent.
The general valuation principles include:
- Open market value.
- Value of like kind and quality.
- Cost-based valuation under Rule 30.
- Reasonable means under Rule 31.
The specific rule and applicable provisos must be considered.
12.2 Full Input Tax Credit Available to Recipient
An important proviso to Rule 28 states that where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit, the value declared in the invoice is deemed to be the open market value of the goods or services.
This can be extremely relevant for group companies.
For example:
Company A supplies taxable management services to Company B.
The parties declare a value of ₹5,00,000.
Company B is eligible for full input tax credit.
Subject to the conditions of Rule 28, the declared invoice value may be deemed to be the open market value.
However, the full-ITC condition must be genuinely satisfied.
12.3 When Full Input Tax Credit Is Not Available
If the receiving company is not eligible for full input tax credit, the valuation rules require more detailed examination.
The business may need to determine the open market value or apply the prescribed alternative valuation methods.
The companies should maintain a reasonable basis for their valuation.
12.4 Salary Cost and Administrative Charges
Depending on the nature of the supply, the taxable value may include relevant employment costs and other amounts forming part of the consideration under Section 15.
These may include:
- Basic salary.
- Allowances.
- Employer contributions.
- Employment-related benefits.
- Administrative charges.
- Other amounts forming part of the agreed consideration.
The inclusion of each component depends on the actual transaction and applicable valuation provisions.
A business should not automatically treat every payroll component as a taxable amount or automatically exclude salary costs from a taxable manpower supply.
13. Input Tax Credit on GST Paid for Secondment Services
Input Tax Credit (ITC) is another important consideration.
If an MSME receives taxable secondment or manpower supply services and GST is charged, the recipient may be eligible to claim ITC subject to Section 16 and other applicable provisions.
13.1 Conditions for Claiming ITC
The recipient should generally ensure that:
- It possesses a valid tax invoice or other prescribed document.
- The supplier has furnished the required invoice details.
- The recipient has received the relevant services.
- The tax charged has been paid to the Government, subject to the statutory framework.
- The recipient has furnished its GST return.
- The credit is not blocked under Section 17(5).
- The expense relates to business activities and satisfies the applicable eligibility requirements.
13.2 Full ITC Versus Restricted ITC
If the receiving company makes only taxable supplies and satisfies all statutory conditions, it may be eligible for full ITC.
However, where the business makes exempt supplies or uses services for non-business purposes, proportionate reversals may be required.
Sections 17(1) and 17(2), read with Rules 42 and 43, should be examined where applicable.
13.3 ITC on Imported Secondment Services
If an Indian company pays IGST under reverse charge on imported manpower or other taxable services, the company may be eligible to claim ITC, provided the relevant statutory conditions are satisfied.
Payment of reverse charge tax and entitlement to ITC are separate compliance considerations.
The company should also examine whether the services are used for taxable business activities and whether any restriction applies.
14. Input Service Distributor: Important Changes Effective From 1 April 2025
MSME group companies with multiple GST registrations must also understand the amended Input Service Distributor (ISD) provisions.
The Finance Act, 2024 amended the ISD framework, with relevant changes becoming effective from 1 April 2025.
The amended provisions expanded the ISD mechanism to include input services received for or on behalf of distinct persons, including specified reverse charge transactions.
The use of the ISD mechanism became mandatory for covered common input services attributable to distinct persons.
14.1 What Is an ISD?
An Input Service Distributor is an office of a supplier that receives invoices for input services on behalf of distinct persons and distributes the eligible input tax credit to those persons under the prescribed mechanism.
For example:
The Maharashtra head office receives a common software subscription invoice used by the Maharashtra, Gujarat and Karnataka registrations.
Where the invoice relates to services received for or on behalf of these distinct persons, the applicable ISD provisions must be considered.
14.2 ISD Versus Cross-Charge
These concepts serve different purposes.
ISD: Distribution of eligible ITC relating to input services procured from third-party suppliers.
Cross-charge: Tax treatment of internally generated services supplied by one distinct person to another.
For example:
- Third-party legal consultancy used by several registrations: examine ISD.
- Internal HR services supplied by the head office to branches: examine cross-charge.
- Foreign group company supplies secondment services: examine the underlying supply and import-of-services treatment.
The same transaction should not be incorrectly classified under the wrong mechanism.
14.3 October 2026 CBIC Clarification
CBIC Circular No. 260/06/2026-GST dated 26 October 2026 provides additional clarification on ISD implementation.
Among other things, it addresses:
- ISD registration requirements for separate business verticals and places of business.
- Eligibility conditions for ITC.
- Distribution of credit in the month in which eligibility is ascertained.
- Responsibility for ITC reversals.
- The treatment of specified Rule 54(1A) invoices.
It clarifies that recipients of distributed credit are responsible for satisfying the applicable ITC eligibility conditions and making the required reversals.
Therefore, MSMEs with multiple GST registrations should review their ISD processes rather than relying on pre-April 2025 procedures.
15. Practical Examples of GST on Employee Secondment
Understanding the law becomes easier when examined through practical business situations.
Example 1: Parent Company Deputes a Finance Manager to Its Subsidiary
ABC Limited owns 100% of XYZ Private Limited.
ABC employs a finance manager and deputes the employee to XYZ.
XYZ reimburses the salary cost every month.
The employee works under XYZ’s management.
GST analysis:
The companies must examine whether the employee has genuinely become an employee of XYZ or whether ABC continues to provide manpower services.
If there is a genuine employer-employee relationship with XYZ, the employee’s services may fall within Schedule III.
If ABC supplies manpower to XYZ, the transaction may be taxable as a service between related persons.
The reimbursement label alone does not determine the result.
Example 2: Foreign Parent Company Deputes an Employee to India
A Singapore-based parent company deputes a senior technical employee to its Indian subsidiary.
The overseas company continues to administer the employee’s employment arrangements and recovers the salary cost from India.
GST analysis:
The arrangement must be examined under the principles discussed in Northern Operating Systems.
If the overseas company is supplying manpower services to the Indian company, the arrangement may constitute an import of services.
The Indian company must examine IGST under reverse charge, subject to the applicable provisions.
Example 3: Head Office Provides HR Services to Branch Offices
An Indian company has separate GST registrations in three states.
The head office employs an HR team that manages recruitment, employee records, payroll coordination and compliance for all three registrations.
GST analysis:
The registrations are distinct persons.
The internal HR services supplied by the head office to other registrations may constitute taxable supplies under Schedule I.
The applicable valuation and invoicing requirements should be examined.
Common third-party HR software or consultancy invoices may separately fall under the ISD framework where attributable to distinct persons.
Example 4: Company A Only Processes Salary Payments
Company A processes salary payments on behalf of Company B under a genuine arrangement where Company B is the employer.
Company B reimburses the exact amounts paid.
GST analysis:
A genuine payment facilitation arrangement should be distinguished from manpower supply.
If Company A provides a separate payroll administration service, that service may require independent GST analysis.
If the arrangement is intended to be treated as a pure agent transaction, the conditions under Rule 33 must be independently satisfied. Merely recovering the exact amount does not establish pure-agent treatment.
Example 5: Employee Works for Two Group Companies
A senior finance manager is employed by Company A but spends 60% of the working time supporting Company A and 40% supporting Company B.
Company A allocates 40% of the salary cost to Company B.
GST analysis:
The companies must examine the actual employment and service arrangement.
If Company A supplies finance or management services to Company B, the allocation may form part of a taxable supply between related persons.
If the companies have distinct GST registrations, Schedule I and the relevant cross-charge principles must also be examined.
The percentage allocation alone does not establish the correct GST treatment.
16. Important Documentation Required for Employee Secondment
Documentation is extremely important when determining the GST treatment of secondment.
MSMEs should maintain the following records:
A. Secondment Agreement
The agreement should clearly specify:
- Names and details of the companies.
- Employee details.
- Duration of secondment.
- Purpose of the assignment.
- Nature of duties.
- Employer responsibilities.
- Salary payment arrangements.
- Reimbursement arrangements.
- Termination conditions.
- Rights and responsibilities of the receiving company.
- Employment benefits.
- Responsibility for statutory contributions.
B. Employment Agreement
Businesses should maintain the original employment agreement and any revised employment documentation.
Where the employee’s employment relationship changes during secondment, the documentation should reflect the actual arrangement.
C. Salary Records
Maintain:
- Salary slips.
- Payroll registers.
- Bank payment details.
- Salary reimbursement statements.
- Employer contribution details.
- Tax deduction records.
D. Operational Control Records
Maintain supporting documents demonstrating who exercises actual employment and operational responsibilities.
These may include:
- Reporting structures.
- Performance appraisal records.
- Leave approval records.
- Disciplinary procedures.
- Work allocation records.
- Employee correspondence.
E. Intercompany Invoices and Accounting Records
Where the transaction is taxable, maintain appropriate tax invoices, debit notes, credit notes and accounting records.
Where the transaction is not taxable, maintain the factual and legal basis for that conclusion.
Proper documentation helps establish the true nature of the arrangement.
17. Common GST Mistakes Made by MSME Group Companies
Many MSMEs unknowingly create GST exposure because of incomplete documentation or incorrect transaction classification.
The following mistakes should be avoided.
Mistake 1: Treating Every Salary Reimbursement as Non-Taxable
A reimbursement is not automatically outside GST.
The underlying transaction must be examined.
Mistake 2: Assuming Common Ownership Means No GST
Separate companies within the same group remain separate legal entities.
Related-party transactions may be taxable even without consideration.
Mistake 3: Applying the Northern Operating Systems Judgment to Every Arrangement
CBIC has expressly clarified that the judgment should not be mechanically applied.
Each arrangement must be evaluated on its own facts.
Mistake 4: Ignoring International Secondment
Foreign secondment arrangements can involve import-of-services and reverse charge implications.
Mistake 5: Incorrect Valuation
Charging GST only on administrative fees without examining the applicable valuation rules may create tax exposure.
Similarly, assuming that all salary components must always be included in every transaction is not necessarily correct.
Mistake 6: Ignoring ITC Conditions
Businesses should not claim ITC merely because GST appears on an invoice.
All statutory conditions must be fulfilled.
Mistake 7: Confusing ISD and Cross-Charge
ISD and cross-charge are different mechanisms.
Misclassification can lead to incorrect credit distribution and tax reporting.
Mistake 8: Not Reviewing Agreements
A secondment arrangement that was originally drafted several years ago may no longer reflect the actual commercial and employment practices.
Agreements should be reviewed periodically.
18. GST Compliance Checklist for MSME Group Companies
Businesses should adopt a structured compliance process for employee secondment.
| Compliance activity | Recommended action |
|---|---|
| Agreement review | Examine secondment and employment agreements |
| Employment analysis | Identify the actual employer |
| Transaction classification | Determine whether there is a taxable service |
| Related-party review | Check Section 15 and Schedule I |
| Import review | Examine foreign secondment and reverse charge |
| Valuation | Apply Section 15 and relevant valuation rules |
| Tax invoice | Issue where a taxable supply exists |
| Reverse charge | Pay applicable tax where required |
| ITC | Verify Section 16 and Section 17 conditions |
| ISD | Review covered common input services |
| GST returns | Reconcile invoices, tax and credits |
| Documentation | Maintain agreements and supporting evidence |
19. Risk Management and GST Audit Preparedness
MSMEs should not wait until receiving a GST notice to review secondment arrangements.
A proactive tax review can help identify potential exposures.
Step 1: Identify all secondment arrangements
Prepare a list of employees deputed between group entities.
Include domestic and international assignments.
Step 2: Classify the arrangements
Separate arrangements into:
- Genuine employment with the receiving entity.
- Manpower supply.
- Management or administrative services.
- Internal services between distinct registrations.
- Foreign secondment arrangements.
Step 3: Review the contractual structure
Compare the agreement with actual business practices.
An agreement may state that the receiving company is the employer, while payroll and employment records may indicate otherwise.
Such inconsistencies can create disputes.
Step 4: Review historical GST treatment
Check whether GST was charged, whether reverse charge was paid and whether ITC was claimed.
Step 5: Examine valuation
Verify whether the transaction was valued correctly.
Step 6: Review available ITC
Confirm that the receiving company is eligible for the claimed credit.
Step 7: Maintain a legal position paper
For material secondment arrangements, prepare a written tax analysis documenting:
- Relevant facts.
- Applicable statutory provisions.
- Judicial precedents.
- CBIC instructions.
- GST classification.
- Valuation approach.
- ITC position.
- Compliance responsibilities.
This can be valuable during a GST audit or departmental investigation.
20. What Happens If GST Is Not Paid on a Taxable Secondment Arrangement?
Where an arrangement constitutes a taxable supply and the applicable GST has not been paid, the department may initiate proceedings under the relevant provisions of the CGST Act.
Potential consequences include:
A. GST Demand
The taxpayer may be required to pay the tax that was not paid or was short-paid.
B. Interest
Interest may be payable under Section 50, subject to the applicable statutory provisions.
C. Penalties
Penalty provisions depend on the nature of the default, applicable section, period and facts of the case.
D. ITC Disputes
Incorrectly claimed or distributed input tax credit may be subject to recovery and applicable interest or penalties.
E. Litigation Expenses
Businesses may also incur professional fees, legal expenses and management time in responding to notices and participating in proceedings.
However, it is important to remember CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023-GST.
Section 74 should not be invoked mechanically merely because GST was not paid. The statutory requirements relating to fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax must be established.
The applicable demand provision should be examined based on the relevant financial year and law in force.
21. Best Practices for MSMEs to Structure Employee Secondment Arrangements
MSMEs can reduce tax uncertainty by following certain practical measures.
1. Prepare a Proper Secondment Agreement
Do not rely only on informal emails or internal management instructions.
The agreement should explain the actual nature of the arrangement.
2. Define Employer Responsibilities
Clearly specify who is responsible for:
- Salary.
- Leave.
- Performance evaluation.
- Employee benefits.
- Disciplinary action.
- Termination.
- Statutory employment obligations.
The contractual terms should reflect actual conduct.
3. Avoid Artificial Reimbursement Structures
Do not create a salary reimbursement arrangement merely to avoid GST where the commercial reality is manpower supply.
4. Maintain Separate Entity Records
Maintain appropriate records for every legal entity and GST registration.
5. Conduct Annual GST Reviews
Review secondment arrangements whenever there is a change in employee responsibilities, reporting structure or payment mechanism.
6. Evaluate Reverse Charge Exposure
International secondment arrangements should be reviewed for import-of-services implications.
7. Implement Proper Cross-Charge and ISD Procedures
Businesses operating through multiple GST registrations should distinguish internally generated services from common third-party input services.
8. Take Professional Advice
Where substantial amounts are involved, obtain a documented GST opinion before implementing or changing the arrangement.
22. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q1. Is GST applicable on employee secondment between group companies?
GST is not automatically applicable to every secondment arrangement. The tax treatment depends on whether the arrangement represents a genuine employer-employee relationship or a taxable supply of manpower or other services.
Q2. Is GST applicable on salary reimbursement between parent and subsidiary companies?
It depends on the actual nature of the transaction. A genuine salary payment under an employment relationship may fall outside GST under Schedule III. However, reimbursement under a manpower supply or other taxable service arrangement may attract GST.
Q3. Does the Northern Operating Systems judgment apply to all secondment arrangements?
No. CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023-GST dated 13 December 2023 specifically clarifies that the judgment should not be mechanically applied to every arrangement. Each case requires an examination of its specific facts and contractual terms.
Q4. Is GST applicable if the parent company does not charge any profit margin?
The absence of a profit margin does not automatically eliminate GST liability. Transactions between related persons may be treated as supplies even without consideration under Schedule I, subject to the applicable conditions.
Q5. Is salary paid to employees taxable under GST?
Ordinary salary paid by an employer to an employee for services in the course of employment is covered by Schedule III and is not treated as a supply under GST.
Q6. Is GST applicable to international employee secondment?
International secondment may attract IGST under reverse charge if the overseas company is supplying taxable services to the Indian recipient and the import-of-services conditions are satisfied. Genuine employment arrangements require separate analysis.
Q7. What is the GST rate applicable to manpower supply?
Manpower supply and similar staffing services are commonly taxable at 18%, subject to the applicable service classification, rate notification and any relevant exemption.
Q8. Can an Indian company claim ITC on GST paid under reverse charge for secondment services?
Yes, subject to the applicable conditions under Sections 16 and 17 of the CGST Act and other relevant provisions.
Q9. What is the difference between cross-charge and ISD?
Cross-charge concerns internally generated services supplied between distinct persons. ISD concerns distribution of eligible input tax credit relating to input services received for or on behalf of distinct persons.
Q10. Is a secondment agreement mandatory?
There is no universal GST rule requiring every secondment arrangement to follow one standard agreement format. However, a properly drafted written agreement is strongly recommended because the contract is an important factor in determining the actual nature of the arrangement.
Q11. Can the GST department demand tax on old secondment arrangements?
The department may examine historical transactions subject to applicable statutory time limits, demand provisions and procedural requirements. The correct provision must be determined based on the relevant financial year and facts.
Q12. Does GST apply when an employee works for two companies within the same group?
The treatment depends on the employment relationship and the services provided. If services are supplied between separate legal entities or distinct GST registrations, related-party and distinct-person provisions may become relevant.
Q13. Does reimbursement of actual salary cost qualify as a pure agent transaction?
Not automatically. Rule 33 of the CGST Rules contains specific conditions for pure-agent treatment. Merely recovering an amount without a markup does not establish that the conditions are satisfied.
Q14. What documents should an MSME maintain for secondment?
Important documents include the secondment agreement, employment agreement, salary records, payroll statements, reimbursement calculations, reporting structures, work allocation records and relevant intercompany invoices.
Q15. Can MSMEs avoid GST by changing the wording of their secondment agreements?
No. Merely changing contractual descriptions does not determine GST treatment. The actual substance and implementation of the arrangement are important.
23. Conclusion: Take a Proactive Approach to GST on Employee Secondment
Employee secondment is an effective business practice for MSME group companies. It helps organisations share skilled employees, reduce recruitment costs, centralise management and improve operational efficiency.
However, secondment arrangements can create complicated GST implications, particularly where multiple companies, different GST registrations or overseas group entities are involved.
The most important lesson is that GST liability depends on the actual nature of the secondment arrangement, not merely on the description of the payment as salary reimbursement.
The Supreme Court’s Northern Operating Systems judgment highlights the importance of examining the substance of the employment and contractual arrangements. CBIC Instruction No. 05/2023-GST further clarifies that every secondment arrangement must be examined independently.
MSMEs should therefore:
- Review secondment and employment agreements.
- Establish the actual employer-employee relationship.
- Identify possible manpower or management service supplies.
- Evaluate related-party and distinct-person provisions.
- Examine import-of-services and reverse charge implications.
- Apply the appropriate valuation rules.
- Verify input tax credit eligibility.
- Follow applicable ISD and cross-charge procedures.
- Maintain comprehensive documentation.
A properly structured secondment arrangement, supported by appropriate agreements and tax documentation, can help businesses minimise uncertainty and avoid unnecessary GST disputes.
Need professional assistance with GST on employee secondment?
CleverCoins helps businesses navigate GST compliance, taxation, registrations and tax-related advisory requirements.
Whether you operate a single MSME or a group of companies with multiple GST registrations, understanding the tax implications of employee secondment can protect your business from avoidable compliance risks.
Visit https://clevercoins.org/ to explore GST services and connect with the CleverCoins team.






