Interest-Free Loan to Sister Concern MSME: Deemed Dividend Tax Under the New Income-tax Act, 2025
Running multiple business entities under a single promoter group is standard practice across India’s Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSME) ecosystem. When one group company enjoys surplus liquidity while a newly incorporated sister concern faces a temporary working capital crunch, the most natural instinct for any business owner is to transfer funds from the cash-rich entity to the cash-strapped entity—often without charging interest and with minimal paperwork.
On paper, it looks like harmless internal cash management. The money never leaves the promoter family, no external bank is involved, and the borrowing company intends to return the funds once its receivables clear.
Yet under Indian tax and corporate law, this exact transaction is one of the sharpest compliance traps an MSME promoter can walk into. With the Income-tax Act, 2025 taking effect for Tax Year 2026-27 onwards (replacing the six-decade-old Income-tax Act, 1961), the tax administration’s scrutiny of closely held companies and inter-corporate fund transfers has only intensified. What a promoter views as a temporary, interest-free accommodation between two MSMEs can be legally recharacterized by the Assessing Officer (AO) as a Deemed Dividend under Section 2(40)(e) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (corresponding to the erstwhile Section 2(22)(e) of the 1961 Act).
Even worse, an interest-free loan between sister concerns does not fail merely under tax law—it simultaneously triggers severe violations under Sections 185 and 186 of the Companies Act, 2013, exposes the lending company to TDS defaults under Section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (erstwhile Section 194), and creates the nightmare scenario of economic double taxation without a single rupee of actual dividend ever being declared.
This guide dissects every legal, accounting, and compliance dimension of giving an interest-free loan to a sister concern MSME, explaining how deemed dividend tax operates under the new Act, who actually pays the tax, where judicial precedents offer protection, and how MSME founders can structure intra-group funding legally.
1. Understanding the Core Concept: What Is a “Sister Concern” in MSME Operations?
Before examining the statutory mechanics, it is essential to clarify what Indian tax and corporate statutes mean by a sister concern. Interestingly, neither the Income-tax Act, 2025 nor the Companies Act, 2013 defines the colloquial phrase “sister concern” in a single standalone clause. Instead, both statutes capture sister concerns through tests of common shareholding, voting power, and control.
In practical MSME structures, sister concerns typically arise in the following scenarios:
Two Private Limited Companies with Common Promoters: Promoter A and Promoter B hold 60% and 40% equity in Alpha Manufacturing Pvt. Ltd. (an established MSME with healthy accumulated reserves) and also hold 50% and 50% equity in Beta Trading Pvt. Ltd. (a newly launched MSME). Neither company owns shares in the other, yet both are controlled by the same individuals.
Private Limited Company and a Partnership Firm or LLP: A promoter holds 30% voting shares in Sigma Engineering Pvt. Ltd. and is also a partner entitled to 40% profit share in Sigma Enterprises (LLP).
Parent-Subsidiary or Associate Structures: Parent Co. Pvt. Ltd. holds 25% or more equity in Associate Co. Pvt. Ltd., or both entities share common directors and key managerial personnel.
Because MSMEs frequently split operations across multiple entities—to ring-fence liabilities, separate manufacturing from trading, qualify for distinct MSME Udyam thresholds, or segregate state-wise GST registrations—inter-entity fund transfers happen constantly. When those transfers take the form of an interest-free loan or advance, Section 2(40)(e) enters the picture.
2. Deemed Dividend Under the Income-tax Act, 2025: Statutory Evolution from Section 2(22)(e) to Section 2(40)(e)
Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, the definition of “dividend” was housed in Section 2(22), with sub-clause (e) specifically targeting loans and advances by closely held companies. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, the entire statute was restructured for readability and simplified numbering, shifting the inclusive definition of “dividend” to Section 2(40) and placing the deemed dividend loan provision under Section 2(40)(e).
Why Does the Law Have a “Deemed Dividend” Provision?
To understand how the tax department enforces this section, you have to understand its anti-abuse legislative intent.
When a closely held company (such as a Private Limited Company) earns profits, it pays corporate income tax. However, those post-tax profits remain locked inside the company’s balance sheet as Accumulated Profits (Reserves and Surplus). If the company formally declares a dividend to distribute those profits to its shareholders, the shareholders must pay personal income tax on that dividend at their applicable slab rates (which can go up to 30% plus surcharge and 4% cess).
Historically, promoters of closely held companies devised a workaround: instead of declaring taxable dividends, the company would simply lend its accumulated profits to its major shareholders—or to another business entity owned by those shareholders—as an “interest-free loan” that remained on the balance sheet indefinitely without ever being repaid. The shareholders enjoyed the cash without paying dividend tax.
Section 2(40)(e) closes this loophole by creating a strict legal fiction: if a closely held company gives a loan or advance out of its accumulated profits to a substantial shareholder—or to a concern in which that shareholder holds a substantial interest—the tax law deems that loan to be a dividend, regardless of what the parties call it in their books.
3. The Four Cumulative Conditions That Trigger Deemed Dividend Tax
A loan or advance to a sister concern does not automatically become a deemed dividend just because two companies share a director. For the Assessing Officer to invoke Section 2(40)(e), four cumulative statutory conditions must all be satisfied simultaneously. If even one condition fails, the deemed dividend addition collapses.
Condition 1: The Lending Company Must Be a “Closely Held Company”
The payer must be a company “in which the public are not substantially interested.”
Covered: All Private Limited Companies and unlisted Public Limited Companies where shares are tightly held by promoters/family members.
Exempt: Listed public companies whose equity shares are freely traded on a recognized stock exchange, or wholly owned subsidiaries of such widely held public companies.
Crucial MSME Note: Having an MSME Udyam Registration or claiming startup recognition provides zero exemption from Section 2(40)(e). Almost every MSME structured as a Private Limited Company qualifies as a closely held company.
Condition 2: The Nature of Payment Must Be a “Loan or Advance”
The payment made by the lending company must be by way of a loan or advance, or a payment made on behalf of or for the individual benefit of a substantial shareholder.
An interest-free fund transfer recorded under “Loans & Advances” or “Inter-Corporate Deposits (ICD)” directly satisfies this condition.
Even if the loan is repaid within the same financial year—or within a few days—the tax liability is triggered the exact moment the funds are disbursed. Subsequent repayment does not extinguish the deemed dividend once triggered.
Condition 3: The Shareholding & “Substantial Interest” Threshold Must Be Met
This is the twin-threshold test that links the lending company to the borrowing sister concern:
10% Threshold in the Lending Company: A person must be a registered and beneficial shareholder holding at least 10% of the voting power (equity shares) in the lending company.
20% Threshold in the Borrowing Sister Concern: That same 10%+ shareholder must hold a “substantial interest” in the borrowing sister concern. Under the Act, a person has a substantial interest in a concern if they are beneficially entitled to:
At least 20% of the voting power (if the sister concern is a Company), OR
At least 20% of the profits of such concern at any time during the tax year (if the sister concern is a Partnership Firm, LLP, HUF, or AOP).
Condition 4: Existence of “Accumulated Profits” on the Date of Disbursement
The amount treated as a deemed dividend is strictly capped at the accumulated profits (whether capitalized or not) possessed by the lending company on the exact date the loan is disbursed.
If Company A has accumulated profits of ₹15,00,000 and lends ₹25,00,000 interest-free to Sister Concern B, only ₹15,00,000 is taxable as a deemed dividend. The remaining ₹10,00,000 is treated as an ordinary loan.
If Company A has accumulated losses (negative reserves) on the date of lending, no deemed dividend can arise, regardless of how large the loan is.
Important Accounting Trap: “Accumulated profits” for tax purposes means commercial profits calculated up to the date of the loan—not merely the balance sheet reserves from the preceding March 31. If a company had zero reserves on April 1, earned ₹12,00,000 profit between April and September, and lent ₹10,00,000 to a sister concern on October 1, the AO will include current-year profits up to October 1 in accumulated profits!
4. The Million-Dollar Question: Who Pays Tax When a Sister Concern Receives the Loan?
This is where most business owners—and even many accountants—make fatal errors during tax assessments.
Suppose Mr. Rohan holds 50% shares in Rohan Tech Pvt. Ltd. (the lending MSME, which has ₹50 lakh in accumulated reserves). Mr. Rohan also holds 50% shares in Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. (the borrowing sister concern MSME). Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. itself does not hold any shares in Rohan Tech Pvt. Ltd.
Rohan Tech Pvt. Ltd. transfers ₹20,00,000 as an interest-free loan to Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd.
Who gets taxed on the ₹20,00,000 deemed dividend? Is it Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. (the recipient company) or Mr. Rohan (the common individual shareholder)?
The Settled Judicial Position: Only the Registered Shareholder Can Be Taxed
Through landmark rulings—most notably the Special Bench decision in ACIT v. Bhaumik Colour Pvt. Ltd. (affirmed by the Bombay High Court in CIT v. Universal Medicare Pvt. Ltd. and upheld in principle by the Supreme Court in CIT v. Ankitech Pvt. Ltd. and National Travel Services)—Indian courts have established a crystal-clear rule:
Deemed dividend can ONLY be assessed in the hands of a person who is a registered and beneficial shareholder of the lending company.
In our example:
Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. received the money, but it is not a shareholder of Rohan Tech Pvt. Ltd. Therefore, Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. cannot be taxed under Section 2(40)(e).
Instead, the tax department will tax Mr. Rohan (the common individual shareholder) on the ₹20,00,000 as “Income from Other Sources” under Section 92 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (erstwhile Section 56), even though Mr. Rohan never received a single rupee into his personal bank account!
What If the Sister Concern Is a Shareholder?
If Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. directly holds 10% or more equity shares in Rohan Tech Pvt. Ltd., then Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. is both the recipient and a registered shareholder. In that scenario:
The deemed dividend is taxed directly in the hands of Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd.
Can Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. claim an inter-corporate dividend deduction under Section 148 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (erstwhile Section 80M)? Only if Rohan Logistics Pvt. Ltd. onward-distributes an equal or greater dividend to its own shareholders at least one month before its income tax return filing due date. If it retains the money in its business, it pays full corporate tax on the deemed dividend.
5. Tax Rates, TDS Compliance, and Economic Double Taxation Under the Income-tax Act, 2025
Since the abolition of Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT) in 2020, all dividends—including deemed dividends—are taxed in the hands of the recipient under the classical system, which continues unchanged under the Income-tax Act, 2025.
1. Tax Rate in the Shareholder’s Hands
Individual / HUF Shareholder: Taxed at applicable income tax slab rates (up to 30% for income exceeding ₹24 lakh under the default new tax regime in Section 202).
Surcharge Cap: A vital relief preserved in the 2025 Act is that the surcharge on dividend income is capped at 15%, even if the shareholder’s total income exceeds ₹2 crore or ₹5 crore (avoiding the 25% or 37% peak surcharge brackets).
Health & Education Cess: 4% applies on tax plus surcharge.
Maximum Effective Tax Rate:
30% + 15% surcharge on tax + 4% cess= 35.88%.Expense Disallowance: Under the Act, no deduction is allowed against dividend income except interest expenditure incurred to earn that dividend, capped at 20% of the gross dividend income. Since an interest-free loan generates zero interest expense for the shareholder, zero deduction is available.
2. TDS Default Trap Under Section 393 (Erstwhile Section 194)
Under Section 393 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (corresponding to Section 194 of the 1961 Act), any domestic company paying a dividend (including a deemed dividend) exceeding ₹5,000 (or applicable statutory threshold) to a resident shareholder must deduct TDS at 10% before making the payment.
Because MSME promoters treat the transfer as an “interest-free loan,” the lending company almost never deducts 10% TDS at the time of transfer.
During scrutiny, the lending company is declared an “Assessee in Default,” triggering 1% per month interest for non-deduction of TDS, 1.5% per month interest for non-deposit, and potential penalty equal to 100% of the TDS amount!
3. The Economic Double Taxation Trap
Consider what happens if the ₹20,00,000 loan is taxed as a deemed dividend in Year 1, and in Year 2 the borrowing sister concern repays the ₹20,00,000 back to the lending company:
Tax Layer 1: The lending company already paid corporate tax (25.17% under Section 200 / erstwhile Section 115BAA) when it originally earned those profits.
Tax Layer 2: The common shareholder pays up to 35.88% tax when the loan is disbursed as a deemed dividend.
No Refund on Repayment: When the sister concern repays the loan, the shareholder does not get a refund of the deemed dividend tax paid!
Only One Set-Off Relief: Under the statutory exclusion clause of Section 2(40), if the lending company subsequently declares a formal dividend and adjusts it against that loan balance, that formal dividend will not be taxed a second time. However, if the loan is simply repaid in cash, the cash returns to the company’s reserves, and if distributed later as a formal dividend, it risks being taxed all over again unless carefully accounted for!
6. Double Jeopardy: Companies Act, 2013 Violations (Sections 185 & 186)
An interest-free loan to a sister concern does not just violate the Income-tax Act—it simultaneously breaches two of the strictest corporate governance provisions under the Companies Act, 2013: Section 185 and Section 186.
1. Section 185: Loans to Directors and Entities in Which Directors Are Interested
Under Section 185(1), a company is strictly prohibited from advancing any loan to its directors or their relatives. Under Section 185(2), a company may advance a loan to “any person in whom any of the director of the company is interested” (which explicitly includes any private company in which a director is a director or member, or any body corporate where 25%+ voting power is held by such directors) ONLY IF two mandatory conditions are fulfilled:
Prior Special Resolution: A Special Resolution (75% shareholder approval) is passed by the lending company in a General Meeting, accompanied by a detailed explanatory statement disclosing full particulars of the loan and the purpose for which it will be used.
Principal Business Activity Restriction: The borrowing sister concern must utilize the loan exclusively for its principal business activities (it cannot use the funds for speculative investments or onward lending).
Private Company Exemption Check: Notification dated June 5, 2015 exempts Private Limited Companies from Section 185 only if all three conditions are met:
No body corporate has invested any money in the share capital of the lending company;
The lending company’s borrowings from banks, financial institutions, or bodies corporate are less than twice its paid-up share capital or ₹50 crore, whichever is lower; AND
The lending company has no subsisting default in repayment of such borrowings at the time of the transaction.
If your MSME has a large working capital CC/OD limit exceeding twice its paid-up share capital (which is extremely common for MSMEs with ₹10 lakh paid-up capital and a ₹50 lakh bank OD!), the private company exemption is completely lost. Violating Section 185 attracts a fine of ₹5 lakh to ₹25 lakh on the company, and imprisonment up to 6 months or fine up to ₹25 lakh on the directors and borrowing entity!
2. Section 186(7): The Mandatory Interest Floor (Why “Interest-Free” Is Illegal Between Companies)
Even if a company complies with Section 185, Section 186 of the Companies Act, 2013 governs all inter-corporate loans.
Monetary Ceiling (Section 186(2)): Total loans, guarantees, and investments cannot exceed the higher of 60% of (Paid-up Share Capital + Free Reserves + Securities Premium) OR 100% of (Free Reserves + Securities Premium) without a prior Special Resolution.
Unanimous Board Resolution (Section 186(5)): Every inter-corporate loan requires a Board Resolution passed with the consent of all directors present at the meeting.
Mandatory Minimum Interest Rate (Section 186(7)): No loan under Section 186 can be given at an interest rate lower than the prevailing yield of 1-year, 3-year, 5-year, or 10-year Government Security (G-Sec) closest to the tenor of the loan.
Key Takeaway: Under Section 186(7), a Private Limited Company is legally prohibited from giving an interest-free loan to a sister concern (unless the borrower is a Wholly Owned Subsidiary, and even there, Section 186(7) does not grant a blanket interest-rate carve-out—making equity or CCPS infusion the preferred route). Giving a 0% interest loan automatically violates Section 186(7), attracting penalties under Section 186(13) and triggering mandatory qualification in the statutory auditor’s CARO (Companies Auditor’s Report Order) report!
7. Quick-Reference Comparison: How Different Intra-Group Transactions Are Taxed & Regulated
| Transaction Type | Deemed Dividend u/s 2(40)(e)? | Companies Act (Sec 185 / 186) Compliance | Deductibility of Interest / Expense | Risk Level for MSMEs |
| Interest-Free Loan to Sister Concern (Common 10%+ & 20%+ Shareholder) | YES (Up to accumulated profits; taxed in common shareholder’s hands) | VIOLATION of Sec 186(7) (below G-Sec yield) & potential Sec 185 breach | No interest charged; high scrutiny & TDS default risk u/s 393 | CRITICAL |
| Interest-Bearing Loan at ≥ G-Sec Yield (with Board/Special Resolution) | YES (Charging interest does not exempt a loan from Sec 2(40)(e)) | COMPLIANT (Subject to Sec 185/186 approvals & MBP-2 register) | Borrower claims interest expense u/s 36(1)(iii); lender pays tax on interest income | HIGH (Tax Risk Remains) |
| Genuine Commercial Trade Advance (For Goods/Services in Ordinary Course) | NO (Protected under settled judicial precedent) | EXEMPT (Trade advances are not loans u/s 185/186) | Normal business purchase/revenue accounting; GST applies on supply | LOW (If Documented) |
| Loan from a Non-Lending Sister Concern with Zero Accumulated Profits | NO (No accumulated profits = ₹0 deemed dividend) | APPLICABLE (Still must charge ≥ G-Sec interest u/s 186(7)) | Normal interest rules apply | MODERATE |
| Equity / Preference Share Subscription by Sister Concern | NO (Capital subscription is not a loan or advance) | COMPLIANT (Subject to Sec 186(2) investment limit & valuation rules) | Capital transaction; no interest drain on borrowing MSME | LOW (Cleanest Structure) |
8. Statutory Exemptions & Judicial Defenses: When Is an Advance NOT a Deemed Dividend?
Not every rupee moving between two MSME sister concerns attracts deemed dividend tax. Both the Income-tax Act, 2025 and a strong body of Supreme Court and High Court jurisprudence carve out specific safe harbors.
Defense 1: Genuine Commercial & Trade Advances (The Business Expediency Rule)
In landmark judgments such as CIT v. Creative Dyeing & Printing Pvt. Ltd. (Delhi High Court, affirmed by the Supreme Court) and CIT v. Ambassador Travels Pvt. Ltd., courts have consistently held that the words “loan or advance” in Section 2(22)(e) [now Section 2(40)(e)] do not include commercial advances made in the ordinary course of business.
When It Applies: If Company A gives an advance to Sister Concern B for the purchase of raw materials, job-work manufacturing, shared warehousing, or execution of a specific customer order, it is a trade advance, not a financial loan.
Proof Required: Purchase orders, supply agreements, past and subsequent trade invoices against which the advance is adjusted, and ledger histories showing regular commercial settlement. If an “advance” sits unadjusted in the books for two years with zero goods supplied, the AO will reclassify it as a disguised loan!
Defense 2: Lending of Money Is a Substantial Part of Business
Under the statutory exception in Section 2(40) (erstwhile sub-clause (ii) of Section 2(22)), any advance or loan made to a shareholder or sister concern by a company in the ordinary course of its business, where the lending of money is a substantial part of the business of the company (such as a registered NBFC), is completely excluded from deemed dividend.
Caution: Simply adding a “money lending” clause in the Memorandum of Association (MoA) without RBI NBFC registration and actual lending operations will not satisfy this test.
Defense 3: Payment for Purchase of Assets on Behalf of Sister Concern
As reiterated by the Mumbai ITAT in Jasubhai Engineering Pvt. Ltd., if one sister concern makes a direct vendor payment on behalf of another sister concern for purchasing machinery or capital assets under a documented business arrangement, it constitutes a commercial transaction rather than a gratuitous loan or advance.
Defense 4: Absence of Beneficial Shareholding Threshold
If the common promoter holds less than 10% voting power in the lending company (for example, 9% held by the husband and 9% held by the wife, assuming no sham arrangement), the first statutory trigger fails. Note that Section 2(40)(e) tests individual registered and beneficial shareholding—shares held by a spouse or relative are not automatically clubbed unless beneficial ownership rests with the same individual.
Defense 5: Recent Supreme Court Backing on Commercial Expediency for Borrowed Funds (2026)
In a notable development in May 2026, the Supreme Court reaffirmed the S.A. Builders “commercial expediency” principle under Section 36(1)(iii), permitting interest deduction on borrowed funds advanced to a sister concern where commercial expediency and group business synergy were established. While this protects the interest expense deduction of the lender under business income provisions, promoters must remember that commercial expediency alone does not override Section 2(40)(e) if the transfer is a pure financial loan out of accumulated profits rather than a trade advance.
9. Step-by-Step Practical Guide: How MSMEs Should Structure Intra-Group Funding Legally
If your established MSME has surplus cash and your sister concern MSME needs funds, follow this structured compliance checklist before initiating any bank transfer:
Step 1: Test the Transaction Against Section 2(40)(e) Before Transferring Funds
Check the Accumulated Profits of the lending company as of the current date (including estimated current-year profits up to the transaction date).
Map the Shareholding Pattern of both entities. Identify whether any common shareholder holds ≥10% voting power in the lender and ≥20% voting power / profit share in the borrower.
If both conditions are positive and the lender has accumulated profits, do not route the funds as an unsecured loan or ICD—doing so guarantees deemed dividend exposure.
Step 2: Choose a Tax-Safe & Companies Act-Compliant Funding Alternative
Depending on your commercial objective, select one of these four legal alternatives:
Commercial Supply / Job-Work Advance (For Operational Synergy): If the two MSMEs operate in complementary verticals (e.g., one manufactures components and the other assembles/markets them), execute a formal Master Supply or Job-Work Agreement. Issue a formal Purchase Order, transfer funds as an advance against supply, issue GST-compliant invoices upon delivery, and adjust the advance in the vendor ledger within the agreed credit cycle.
Equity or Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS) Infusion (For Long-Term Capital): If the sister concern needs long-term growth capital, have the cash-rich entity subscribe to fresh equity shares or CCPS of the sister concern after obtaining a Rule 11UA / Registered Valuer valuation report. Capital infusion does not attract Section 2(40)(e) and avoids ongoing interest drain.
Inter-Corporate Loan Strictly Compliant with Sections 185 & 186 (Only When Lender Has Zero Accumulated Profits):If the lending company has accumulated losses (zero accumulated profits), Section 2(40)(e) cannot apply. In that case, execute a formal Loan Agreement charging interest at or above the prevailing G-Sec yield (e.g., 1-year or 3-year G-Sec rate), pass a unanimous Board Resolution (and Special Resolution if required under Sections 185/186), record the entry in Form MBP-2 within 7 days, and deduct 10% TDS on interest under Section 393 / erstwhile Section 194A.
Formal Dividend + Shareholder Infusion (When Reserves Are Large and Personal Slab Is Low):If the common shareholders fall in lower personal income tax slabs (or have family members holding genuine shares whose total income stays within the ₹12 lakh rebate threshold under Section 156 of the Income-tax Act, 2025), declaring a formal dividend, paying nominal tax, and infusing personal funds as unsecured director’s loan into the sister concern completely eliminates corporate-level Section 185/186 and Section 2(40)(e) litigation.
Step 3: Maintain Audit-Ready Documentation
Regardless of the route chosen, maintain a dedicated compliance file containing:
Signed Board Resolutions and General Meeting Special Resolutions (with explanatory statements).
Updated Form MBP-2 (Register of Loans, Guarantees, Security and Acquisition Made by the Company).
Signed Inter-Corporate Loan Agreement or Commercial Supply Contract specifying tenor, interest rate (benchmarked to RBI G-Sec yield), and repayment schedule.
Ledger confirmations and bank trail showing clean accounting classification (never use vague narration like “Temporary Adjustment” or “Hand Loan” in bank transfers).
10. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does charging market interest protect a loan to a sister concern from deemed dividend tax?
No. A common myth among MSME promoters is that charging 9% or 12% interest eliminates deemed dividend risk. Section 2(40)(e) of the Income-tax Act, 2025 makes no distinction between interest-free and interest-bearing loans. Charging interest at or above the G-Sec yield is required to comply with Section 186(7) of the Companies Act, 2013, not to escape Income Tax.
2. If the sister concern repays the interest-free loan before March 31, is deemed dividend tax avoided?
No. Deemed dividend tax is triggered on the exact date the loan is disbursed out of accumulated profits. Even if the borrowing sister concern returns the entire amount within the same financial year—or even within 48 hours—the deemed dividend liability remains legally intact.
3. Does Section 2(40)(e) apply if a Partnership Firm or LLP gives an interest-free loan to a Private Limited Company?
No. Section 2(40)(e) applies only when the lender is a closely held company. If a Partnership Firm, LLP, or Sole Proprietorship lends interest-free funds to a sister Private Limited Company, Section 2(40)(e) does not apply (though transfer pricing or notional interest disallowance under Section 36(1)(iii) may still be examined if the firm itself is paying interest on borrowed bank funds).
4. What if an MSME Private Limited Company gives an interest-free loan to its Wholly Owned Subsidiary (WOS)?
Under Section 2(40)(e), if a parent Private Limited Company holds 100% shares in its subsidiary (which is ≥20% substantial interest), and a common individual holds ≥10% in the parent company, a loan from the parent to the subsidiary can still trigger Section 2(40)(e) in the hands of the common individual shareholder! Under the Companies Act, 2013, loans to a Wholly Owned Subsidiary are exempt from Section 185(1)/(2) and Section 186(3) Special Resolution requirements, but Section 186(7) still requires charging G-Sec interest. Therefore, funding a WOS via equity share subscription is always safer than an interest-free loan.
5. Is GST applicable on an interest-free loan between sister concerns?
No. Under GST law, transactions in money (pure loans and deposits) are neither goods nor services, and interest on loans is exempt under Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate). However, if the transfer is structured as a commercial trade advance for the future supply of taxable goods or services, GST liability on the advance (for services) or upon invoicing (for goods) must be carefully tracked.
Disclaimer: This article is prepared for educational and informational purposes based on the provisions of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (effective Tax Year 2026-27) and the Companies Act, 2013. Inter-corporate transactions carry significant tax and corporate law consequences; always consult a qualified Chartered Accountant or tax advisor before executing intra-group fund transfers.




